Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows - Midnight, July 21st

[GypsyTrash]

Poor Tonks and Lupin.

[Pink punk]

I'd love to read Hogwarts: A History, or The History of Magic. Proper versions though, not Comic Relief style kids books.

Should we start a new thread for those who have read the books and know what happens? That way this one can be left for comjecture from those who've not finished. Or is that pointless?

[Hammer]

Originally Posted by GypsyTrash

Poor Tonks and Lupin.

To be fair It's not like they were major characters or anything. They could have been, but Rowling never bothered to expand on their characters in the previous books.

they killed off dobby, poor houself, it was a veritable slaughter of characters though and i like that she explained why snape killed dumbledore

I was quite glad of that. That character always seemed to be an addon. He was also way to annoying.

Originally Posted by Pink punk

Should we start a new thread for those who have read the books and know what happens? That way this one can be left for comjecture from those who've not finished. Or is that pointless?

Wouldn't be pointless, but we might as well leave it now that folks have been discussing it. There has to be a cut off point for when things are considered spoliers.

I'm glad there won't be any more. There are far too many stories that are streched too far. Harry Potter should end now. it is the right place for the saga to end.

[James]

I loved the book.

I thought Hagrid was a goner when he was dragged into the forest

[James]

I was 2nd in the queue at the asda Govan. Woot!

I was so shocked when Mrs Weasley killed Bellatrix, I well wanted it to be Neville

[Charlie Parker]

Originally Posted by Addy

What are the critics saying about it, incidentally?

it's shite

[Reno]

Aye, we get the hint, you don't like it.

[Charlie Parker]

I actually did read a review that said the film was rubbish

[James]

The film was really good actually. Not as good as hairspray though