Alternative Nation
Go Back   Alternative Nation > Bands & Music > Music Articles
This Charming Girl

Notices

Comment
 
Review Tools
<!-- google_ad_section_start -->Gossip - Jealous Girls (single)<!-- google_ad_section_end -->
Gossip - Jealous Girls (single)
Published by GoddamnElectric
18th August 2007
Gossip - Jealous Girls (single)

Jealous Girls is the latest track from punk three-piece Gossip, who are currently on tour all across Europe bringing their “deep south” sound to the masses.

I’ve never been much of a punk fan, but Gossip have still appealed to me somewhat through their fairly unique sound – vocalist Beth Ditto is consistently strong and gritty, easily selling whatever it is that she’s singing. I won’t digress into the almost cult-like following Ditto has gathered in recent times (especially since her coverage in NME in 2006) as, in my opinion, this would only prejudice the listener one way or another. You probably already either love her or hate her anyway.

This latest single release continues in Gossip’s established style, but also mixes in a slightly more modern sound to the band—minor but still detectable influences of indie and modern rock creep through here and there and create something really quite interesting. Despite claiming to have loathed every second of touring with indie acts like Scissor Sisters one might suggest the mainstream sound has left a footprint on Gossip’s own work ever since, although I wouldn’t say that to their face! This is by no means an earth shattering redefinition of the genre, but it's nice to have a break from the usual punk three chord progressions.

Also included on this single release is a live recording of Jealous Girls, which is really very good indeed. Sometimes the energy and clarity of a decent track can be lost in poor live performances, but not in this instance. The live recording is very competent and possibly a better listen than the radio edit, and is also a good indicator that Gossip are more than capable of entertaining the crowds at a live venue. B-side Coal To Diamonds is a slow and morose ballad, which while a little bland is enjoyable enough for what it is.

With a band like Gossip it almost feels futile to critically review a new release, since everyone who knows them is most likely either a die-hard fan or an outspoken hater of their image, music and damn near everything else about them. If however you’ve never heard any of their music then I would suggest that you not start with Jealous Girls—their 2006 breakthrough track Standing In The Way Of Control is a safer choice, and in my opinion the band has yet to come up with a better tune.

I enjoyed this single release as a welcome break from my usual playlists, however I wouldn’t be too quick to recommend it elsewhere. Ditto’s vocal style is certainly something worth hearing, but the actual track has only a small amount of replay value. Better suited to an alternative club playlist than your home library.


Jealous Girls is out now on Backyard Records


www.myspace.com/gossipband
www.back-yard.co.uk
Old 18th August 2007, 10:58pm  
Pantgirl
Pillowpants
Moderator
 
Pantgirl's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Granny Land
Posts: 16,544
Images: 396
Pantgirl has all the fancy movesPantgirl has all the fancy movesPantgirl has all the fancy movesPantgirl has all the fancy movesPantgirl has all the fancy movesPantgirl has all the fancy movesPantgirl has all the fancy movesPantgirl has all the fancy movesPantgirl has all the fancy movesPantgirl has all the fancy movesPantgirl has all the fancy moves
Send a message via AIM to Pantgirl Send a message via MSN to Pantgirl
Re: Gossip - Jealous Girls (single)

I would never have classified The Gossip as Punk maybe that's just me
__________________
VetBlog
Pantgirl is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 18th August 2007, 10:59pm  
Hammer
Sith Triumvir
Moderator
 
Hammer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: RFS Ravager
Posts: 16,621
Images: 240
Hammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pub
Send a message via MSN to Hammer
Re: Gossip - Jealous Girls (single)

I had a listen to the tracks on their MySpace, and I think I'd be hard pushed to described them as punk. Indie pop or indie rock, yeah but not punk.
These crazy kids and their mixed up music genres.
Hammer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th August 2007, 8:50am  
GoddamnElectric
Meatbag
 
GoddamnElectric's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Glasgow
Posts: 15,918
Images: 85
GoddamnElectric is punker than youGoddamnElectric is punker than youGoddamnElectric is punker than youGoddamnElectric is punker than youGoddamnElectric is punker than youGoddamnElectric is punker than youGoddamnElectric is punker than youGoddamnElectric is punker than youGoddamnElectric is punker than youGoddamnElectric is punker than you
Re: Gossip - Jealous Girls (single)

For the record they describe themselves as punk, hence why it's labelled as a punk article. I couldn't be bothered dredging through the possible alternative genres to find a better match.
__________________
May you never go to hell
But always be on your way there.

GoddamnElectric is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th August 2007, 12:53pm  
Woolies
Should Be Working
 
Woolies's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Woodlands
Posts: 16,580
Blog Entries: 89
Images: 1034
Woolies is almost as cool as crunchy frogWoolies is almost as cool as crunchy frogWoolies is almost as cool as crunchy frogWoolies is almost as cool as crunchy frogWoolies is almost as cool as crunchy frogWoolies is almost as cool as crunchy frogWoolies is almost as cool as crunchy frogWoolies is almost as cool as crunchy frogWoolies is almost as cool as crunchy frogWoolies is almost as cool as crunchy frogWoolies is almost as cool as crunchy frog
Re: Gossip - Jealous Girls (single)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Hammer View Post
I think I'd be hard pushed to described them as punk.
I found this hitting me hard the other day.

I got a new CD in about which everything was labelled as punk and got me quite keen to listen to it. Gave it a play and discovered the tunes are nothing but lame indie-pop-rock Fall Out Boy wannabe gumph. As much relation to what I thought of as Punk as Top Shop t-shirts emblazoned with sparkly "punk" or "ramones" logos.

I sympathised with fans of Aretha Franklin, Elmore James & their ilk, understanding how they must feel when looking at R&B charts.

R&B has very slight similarity to Rhythm & Blues, todays punk has very little similarity to my definition of Punk. The word has changed meaning as a label genre it seems, and not for the better.

Damn stupid punk kids.
Woolies is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th August 2007, 2:42pm  
djtoast
ShakingTheDisease
SuperMod
 
djtoast's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Ptolomea
Posts: 20,823
Images: 164
djtoast is better than Hoodydjtoast is better than Hoodydjtoast is better than Hoodydjtoast is better than Hoodydjtoast is better than Hoodydjtoast is better than Hoodydjtoast is better than Hoodydjtoast is better than Hoodydjtoast is better than Hoodydjtoast is better than Hoodydjtoast is better than Hoody
Re: Gossip - Jealous Girls (single)

I think electroclash is the closest pigeonhole for 'em; despite using live drums it's a very 4/4 sound and the remixes by people like Soulwax and Le Tigre and (for this single) NYPC, dolby-anol and alavi rerox show how comfortably their music sits with more obvious electronica.

It's not surprising that people want to latch onto the allure of some sort of latterly-constructed and nostalgic version of punk attitude; after all, if you ask a businessman in a suit if he values ideas like personal freedom and non-conformity, he'll nod his head and show you the zany lining in his jacket to show just how non-conformist he is. Opposition to ID cards and the war in Iraq bring the punk ethos and Ordinary Joe closer together; likewise the (now quite mainstream) McDonalds/Starbucks backlash.

I guess it's just an inevitability that someone somewhere spots the commercial value in anything - "Wear this Ramones T-shirt (yours for only £15 in HMV) and you'll demonstrate to yourself and others how disaffected with mainstream politics you are (and who isn't?), how thorough your musical knowledge is (after all, The Ramones are, like, old), etc etc
__________________
djtoast is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th August 2007, 5:21pm  
Hammer
Sith Triumvir
Moderator
 
Hammer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: RFS Ravager
Posts: 16,621
Images: 240
Hammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pubHammer is off to the pub
Send a message via MSN to Hammer
Re: Gossip - Jealous Girls (single)

Quote:
Originally Posted by GoddamnElectric View Post
For the record they describe themselves as punk, hence why it's labelled as a punk article. I couldn't be bothered dredging through the possible alternative genres to find a better match.
Aye. Thought that was the case. Bloody PR writers.
Hammer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th August 2007, 5:28pm  
Adele
poster of a girl
 
Adele's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Glasgow
Posts: 1,548
Images: 92
Adele has more friends than you :pAdele has more friends than you :p
Re: Gossip - Jealous Girls (single)

I love this song, actually, I just love (the) Gossip.
Adele is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 19th August 2007, 5:30pm  
Foxglove
Frankly my dear.....

Editor
 
Foxglove's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Paradise City
Posts: 11,320
Images: 34
Foxglove manipulated this rep message for their own purposesFoxglove manipulated this rep message for their own purposesFoxglove manipulated this rep message for their own purposesFoxglove manipulated this rep message for their own purposesFoxglove manipulated this rep message for their own purposesFoxglove manipulated this rep message for their own purposesFoxglove manipulated this rep message for their own purposesFoxglove manipulated this rep message for their own purposes
Re: Gossip - Jealous Girls (single)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Hammer View Post
Aye. Thought that was the case. Bloody PR writers.
The junk that comes with some PR is incredible. I put articles into the area of music I think the band fits rather than what the PR people want to suggest it should be seen as. It may often be the same thing, but if it isn't I go with what I think rather than the PR info.
__________________
I want to teach the world, but not a song.
I need to tell them where they're going wrong:
To trust to serendipity not fate:
To just believe your heart and conjugate.
Foxglove is offline   Reply With Quote
Comment

Bookmarks
Digg del.icio.us StumbleUpon Google

Review Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off


Sin 



 Bamboo





Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.0.0
Advertisement
   



All times are GMT +0. The time now is 7:37am.

Forums Directory
Copyright 2000-2008, Alternative Nation
Review powered by GARS 2.1.8m ©2005-2006

SEO by vBSEO 3.1.0 ©2007, Crawlability, Inc.
Page generated in 0.69038 seconds with 19 queries